View Single Post
Old 23-06-2008, 06:40 PM   #42 (permalink)
lewinb
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 12
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
lewinb's system
Re: N299 1000Mbit speed issues & Drive Spindown (#LMY-14042-345)

Originally Posted by Thecus - Yvon View Post
Dear Sir,

1. Due to N299 CPU performance limitation, thus N299 network performance can’t same with N2100 or other high performance model, if need higher performance model we would recommend for N2100 is a good choose, on theory N299 performance about 40~70% from N2100 and following media review for your reference:

[Links deleted in quote]

2. N299 doesn’t support spin down fucntion, only N2100 support this function.

Yvon.
I think you're missing the point. Either model is DISMALLY slow, based on what is advertised. Even with properly configured gigabit ethernet, the n2100 with the "new, faster" firmware barely breaks over the limit for 100mb ethernet, especially for large files. The speed tests from the smallnetbuilder link you provided bears this out. In fact, for large files, the performance dips BELOW the 12.5 Mbyte limit, even on GB ethernet... GB ethernet is supposed to have a maximum throughput of 125 Mbytes per second!!!! This is according the to info at the link you provided! Please accept my apologies if I am misinterpreting the results, but I don't think I am.

The point is, that even under optimal conditions, the n2100 (and clearly the n299 also) are providing ridiculously substandard speeds for GB ethernet, and it is VERY misleading to advertise them as "gigabit ethernet" when they only attain (top) transfer speeds at or around the maximum for 100MB ethernet. When you advertise that they have "gigabit ethernet", that creates certain expectations on the customers part. Namely, that it will actually PERFORM at these speeds.

On the other hand, having owned an n2100 for nearly two years, I am pleased with the wide range of modules that are available for it (many apparently user-created, I should add). And I should also note that the pathetic speeds are my sole disappointment with the unit.
lewinb is offline   Reply With Quote