View Single Post
Old 25-09-2008, 06:45 PM   #10 (permalink)
stevie lee
the LAN is coming!
 
stevie lee's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Southport
Posts: 1,237
Thanks: 140
Thanked 93 Times in 83 Posts
stevie lee's system
Re: Reviews - Corsair SURVIVOR 32GB review and execution

Originally Posted by Jenny_Y8S View Post
Yet another review where an item is destroyed under a ridiculous and pointless test.

Can't you create some tests that simulate real world conditions before moving onto the crazy stunts. How about:-

- Dunking in a pint of beer - simulates itself.
- Standing on
- Scraping against bricks
- Repeatedly dropped
- Slightly crushed (Don't put it in a bench vice on the 1st go)
- Giving it a run in a rock tumbler

Come on guys, you can do better. Tell us what it "will" survive, and then move on to all the fun and games.
dunking - how about cooking it? or boiling it.
standing - tank? 'slightly' squashed it or how about running over it in a car.
scraping against bricks - wedge+tarinder+hitting a brick wall = the same effect..
dropped - 20ft drop not high enough?
slightly crushed - <see standing>
run in a rock tumbler - hows about lots of little tiny rock shaped things (bullets) hitting it instead?

if it can survive that lot, I think it'll survive someone dropping it in the toilet, fishing it out, dropping it onto bathroom floor because its icky, accidentally standing on it when trying to pick it up, then giving it a dry in a tumble dryer.. (your suggestions but in a normal everyday situation.)
stevie lee is offline   Reply With Quote