Re: Fan specialist needed
I'd have thought any general electronics store should be able to help. I don't know if you're near a city but most have some kind of independent/family run electronics stores where you can just take the thing in and they'd be able to sort you out.
Going for a national/online supplier like RS would be more expensive, and the onus will be on you to order the correctly specified parts and do the component swaps yourself.
Re: Fan specialist needed
Cheers, that's something I didn't consider.
My logic was, since it's a fairly specialised bit of kit, I'd be better of with a specialised place, but I might visit some local repair shops to see what they can do
Re: Fan specialist needed
might be worth looking for TV repair centres. I know it's an old idea to fix a telly but as Kalniel says, you need some old school skills
Re: Fan specialist needed
What you really want is an independent vehicle mechanic, who is very familiar with BMWs, who builds and overclocks PCs in his spare time, and who happens to have a degree in thermodynamics..... Luckily, I happen to have just such a friend.
Are you anywhere near Reading? :)
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Zak33
might be worth looking for TV repair centres. I know it's an old idea to fix a telly but as Kalniel says, you need some old school skills
yep, I was somewhat surprised to find out general computer/phone repair shops won't touch it. I guess they just want to focus on what they know best.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ttaskmaster
What you really want is an independent vehicle mechanic, who is very familiar with BMWs, who builds and overclocks PCs in his spare time, and who happens to have a degree in thermodynamics..... Luckily, I happen to have just such a friend.
Are you anywhere near Reading? :)
Well, the way I look at it, they can have no familiarity with BMWs, or cars, at all, as apart from *being on the car*, it's fairly standalone.
Unless this was a sarcastic joke, I would love to speak to your friend, and as luck would have it, I am very much near Reading. PM?
Re: Fan specialist needed
This is sounding hopeful, but just to note you'll need 15 (non-spammy) posts before PMs get enabled, so don't think you're being ignored :)
Re: Fan specialist needed
Ah, well, I just notice how locked down the profile is.
I wonder if your friend is on the forum, Ttaskmaster ? Or we can keep the initial discussion here, not much of a commercial secret at this point
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
4004
Well, the way I look at it, they can have no familiarity with BMWs, or cars, at all, as apart from *being on the car*, it's fairly standalone.
Unless this was a sarcastic joke, I would love to speak to your friend, and as luck would have it, I am very much near Reading. PM?
Familiarity with the cars will help, as it means he'll at least be aware of any conflicts with the CAN bus and other electrickery gremlins that might (and probably will) arise... and in this case, he has the common diagnostic software and connectivity cables for most brands.
But no, this was not sarcastic.
He's not on this forum, but I can forward on any details. Let me know as much as you can, specifically regarding the components, any model numbers and so on, as well as the specifics of what you want done and what you're hoping to achieve. The more he knows, the better.
Of course no guarantees he'll even be interested, or he may leap at the idea - All I can do for now is ask.
You being close by will help - When you say close, are we talking Oxford, Newbury, or more like spitting distance of The Oracle?
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ttaskmaster
Familiarity with the cars will help, as it means he'll at least be aware of any conflicts with the CAN bus and other electrickery gremlins that might (and probably will) arise... and in this case, he has the common diagnostic software and connectivity cables for most brands.
True, although this kit is so standalone, I reckon it would require his PC building skills more than car skills.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ttaskmaster
But no, this was not sarcastic.
He's not on this forum, but I can forward on any details. Let me know as much as you can, specifically regarding the components, any model numbers and so on, as well as the specifics of what you want done and what you're hoping to achieve. The more he knows, the better.
Of course no guarantees he'll even be interested, or he may leap at the idea - All I can do for now is ask.
Understandable - I've spoken to a few people that do have the knowledge, but either don't have the time or are not interested.
The kit itself is BMW p/n 54130302925, but that's unlikely to provide much detail.
Main bit is the fan unit, with 6x IP44 fans, 70x15mm. Fan p/n seems to be 030811KA, but that doesn't show up anywhere, so I can't tell what sort of RPM/cfm/power draw they are rated for.
The enclosure they snap into is fairly small, and while there might be space to go thicker than 15mm, 70mm is likely the limit for height/width (unless he's got a 3D printer too).
The base goal is to replace the fans with something modern (eg sleeve bearing, to get a quieter design; more airflow is a plus but not a requirement).
I think ebm-papst might offer fans that fit the bill, but not sure about dust resistance.
A potential challenge is that, from what I understand, the current fans are 2-wire, and so are the board connectors, so newer fans might require tinkering with the pcb/connectors.
Stretch goal is replacing the capacitors on the board with something more modern (not sure how much that tech has advanced since 2004), and integrating either a thermistor or some other fan controller, to vary RPM based on temperature.
I've seen fans in this size with an integrated thermal probe, but they are all calibrated to PC case temperatures (30+), whereas this will likely be lower.
Of course, willing to listen to suggestions from people, as my knowledge of cooling hardware is limited.
A photo to give some context - that's the main board where the solar panel and fans connect
https://thumbsnap.com/s/yk2VYGUG.jpg?0521
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ttaskmaster
You being close by will help - When you say close, are we talking Oxford, Newbury, or more like spitting distance of The Oracle?
I'm in Calcot - had to do a double take when you mentioned Reading, and checked if I included location in the profile.
Of course, prepared to travel a bit (going to Surrey this Sa to pick up a missing piece from the kit that was fabricated).
Re: Fan specialist needed
I hear there's a very popular specialist website called Only Fans...
Re: Fan specialist needed
Standard sleeve bearings are quieter only initially. They tend to wear out quicker,and will get noisier and noiser over time,and are more vulnerable to getting dust into the bearings.
The 70X15MM size is not so common nowadays.
However,looking at Farnell and RS Components there are a few choices in that size range:
https://uk.farnell.com/w/c/cooling-t..._1002379_EN_GB
https://uk.rs-online.com/web/c/hvac-...597,4294857989
Panasonic/NMB-MAT also make one such fan:
https://www.ebay.co.uk/sch/i.html?_f...ndition=3%7C10
It uses a ball bearing. Some US websites sell it brand new,but I haven't seen it for sale on major UK suppliers.
Edit!!
Digikey has a decent choice of fans in both 12V and 24V versions using 2 pins:
https://www.digikey.co.uk/products/e...=1&pageSize=25
However,I can only find IP55/IP57 protected fans in 60MM sizes:
https://www.digikey.co.uk/products/e...=1&pageSize=25
I would check the data sheets of the 70MM fans listed on the websites to see if they are IP44/IP55/IP57 rated.
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spacein_vader
I hear there's a very popular specialist website called Only Fans...
oh yeah, sadly I think they focus more on sales rather installation and after sales support.
Plus there are too many specialists there, so I'd need a recommendation.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CAT-THE-FIFTH
Standard sleeve bearings are quieter only initially. They tend to wear out quicker,and will get noisier and noiser over time,and are more vulnerable to getting dust into the bearings.
I wouldn't be too worried as it's unlikely to get too many cycles, but dust would be a problem - hence the IP44 rating on the current ones. Sleeve bearing was just an example - I am not very up to speed on bearing technology, maybe there is something else out there.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CAT-THE-FIFTH
The 70X15MM size is not so common nowadays.
However,looking at Farnell and RS Components there are a few choices in that size range:
Panasonic/NMB-MAT also make one such fan
It uses a ball bearing. Some US websites sell it brand new,but I haven't seen it for sale on major UK suppliers.
Edit!!
Digikey has a decent choice of fans in both 12V and 24V versions using 2 pins
However,I can only find IP55/IP57 protected fans in 60MM sizes
I would check the data sheets of the 70MM fans listed on the websites to see if they are IP44/IP55/IP57 rated.
Yes, that's what I found as well, there isn't too much choice in this size, and what is there doesn't seem to offer any IP protection (not mentioned on data sheets)
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
4004
The tech is early-2000's vintage, so I am thinking there are efficiency gains to be had.
And there's me thinking that's quite modern :)
What does this thing actually *do*?? Solar panels and supercapacitors all sound fun, but there may just be a whole better way of doing whatever this thing does now. Odd to see axial fans used in cars as well, you almost always get snail blowers to get enough air moved.
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DanceswithUnix
Odd to see axial fans used in cars as well, you almost always get snail blowers to get enough air moved.
Don't know about cars but fan attributes generally;
- Axial, higher airflow, lower pressure, lower input power.
- Centrifugal (blower), lower airflow, higher pressure, higher input power.
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
matts-uk
Don't know about cars but fan attributes generally;
- Axial, higher airflow, lower pressure, lower input power.
- Centrifugal (blower), lower airflow, higher pressure, higher input power.
I guess all that ducting to the vents has some backpressure to it. My kit car has a large axial fan in the heater matrix box. It doesn't work, so if the car isn't moving the screen starts to mist up in some conditions. All the other fans I've come across in cars (other than LED lightbulb cooling) are big blowers.
Edit: OFC I'm forgetting those big fans strapped to the engine radiator.
Re: Fan specialist needed
Judging by the aforementioned drawbacks of sleeve bearings, it might be modern enough.
The fans are supposed to draw out hot air through the cracked sunroof. There may well be better ways of doing this (eg the way VAG vehicles do it where the panel powers the a/c), but it will be more complicated to implement (and here I thought swapping out the fans would be easy).
Centrifugal fans fit a very specific use case/placement (in my mind), whereas axial can generally fit and work in most places. Seat ventilation (definitely the older systems) was axial, from memory (Got a kit for that as well, but it's more integrated with the car so I'm leaving it well alone)
Re: Fan specialist needed
I have activated PM for you, 4004
Seems legit reasonb to do so, you're not spamming anything and its an interesting job :)
Re: Fan specialist needed
Sorry for the delay - Matey finally got back to me, but unfortunately he's not in a position to take on anything new right now. The lifting of lockdown restrictions has gotten more people trying to go out and finding that their cars have deteriorated after being sat unused, so his workload has seen a massive spike and all his staff are fully booked for weeks ahead.
However, he may get a slot or have some free time later on, so I'll PM you his number.
Re: Fan specialist needed
Thanks Zak33, promise I won't message people about crypto giveaways by Musk.
TTaskmaster, cheers, that's what I've heard from other mechanics - will message him later. Before I do, did he indicate whether the project made sense to him at all?
Re: Fan specialist needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
4004
TTaskmaster, cheers, that's what I've heard from other mechanics - will message him later. Before I do, did he indicate whether the project made sense to him at all?
I believe he understands the basics of what you want... at least as much as I've been able to explain it. Your photos on the other forum were more useful.
He has a passing awareness of the product and can certainly see why manufacturers dropped such things.
However, he thinks that kind of electrickery will be of more interest to one of his staff than him personally. Have a chat, maybe go meet up and see - It's only a local hop, so even if he says no, you only spend a quid on fuel and still get out of the house for a bit.
