News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Governing body may introduce licence fee for iPlayer users.
Read more.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Personally have no issue with this, as long as my license fee reflects the additional revenue they will be receiving due to the change...
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
0.2% of viewers use iPlayer? I thought it would be higher than that?
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
And how, exactly, do they plan on enforcing this? Will ISPs be forced to hand over the details of people accessing the services? Or does everyone with an internet connection get pestered whether they use iPlayer or not?
Another great boot in the gob for web neutrality then... :rolleyes:
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
'However, the governing body is concerned that as catch-up TV becomes increasingly popular, and available across a wide range of platforms, users may decide to do all their TV watching online and therefore escape the licence fee completely.'
Don't you have to have a TV license if you own a TV, regardless if you only use it for playing games on consoles. Hence its called a TV licence, not a BBC licence.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Originally Posted by
scaryjim
And how, exactly, do they plan on enforcing this?
Simple registering for iplayer and providing your TV licence number I would imagine would be the easiest way to enforce it.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dave87
0.2% of viewers use iPlayer? I thought it would be higher than that?
No, the article is a little too truncated IMO. The source reads:
Quote:
The BBC insists that no changes are needed, pointing to its own research showing that only 0.2% of households watch only catch-up television, with no live viewing, each week.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Brewster0101
'However, the governing body is concerned that as catch-up TV becomes increasingly popular, and available across a wide range of platforms, users may decide to do all their TV watching online and therefore escape the licence fee completely.'
Don't you have to have a TV license if you own a TV, regardless if you only use it for playing games on consoles. Hence its called a TV licence, not a BBC licence.
Nope, it's only if you watch broadcast TV. Similarly, it applies if you use a laptop or mobile phone, yet it's still a "TV License". The on demand isn't live, so it doesn't count as "broadcast TV" which is the loophole described here.
You can own a TV and use it for playing games and not have to pay a license.
Quote:
You need to be covered by a valid TV Licence if you watch or record TV as it's being broadcast. This includes the use of devices such as a computer, laptop, mobile phone or DVD/video recorder.
I'd post a link to the site that says this, but I can't just yet.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Originally Posted by
pauldarkside
... The
source reads:
Quote:
The BBC insists that no changes are needed, pointing to its own research showing that only 0.2% of households watch only catch-up television, with no live viewing, each week.
Actually, that's a fairly large number of households assuming the % is across all UK households - current estimate is around 27 millions UK households, so about 54,000 don't have a TV license but still watch BBC catch-up content via iPlayer. That's close on £8million in license fees if they were all forced to pay up...
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
I'd be happy with an ad supported iPlayer (doen't that happen overseas if you access BBC services?) - but that just won't happen.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
@scaryjim The point I was getting at was that the Hexus article says "only a small percentage (0.2 percent) of its viewers use the iPlayer." That's completely different to what the Guardian are saying; "only 0.2% of households watch only catch-up television, with no live viewing, each week." Those two quotes don't mean the same thing.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Brewster0101
'However, the governing body is concerned that as catch-up TV becomes increasingly popular, and available across a wide range of platforms, users may decide to do all their TV watching online and therefore escape the licence fee completely.'
Don't you have to have a TV license if you own a TV, regardless if you only use it for playing games on consoles. Hence its called a TV licence, not a BBC licence.
Nope, according to http://www.tvlicensing.co.uk/check-if-you-need-one:
Quote:
You need to be covered by a valid TV Licence if you watch or record TV as it's being broadcast.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
shaithis
Personally have no issue with this, as long as my license fee reflects the additional revenue they will be receiving due to the change...
A cut in license would be nice, but I suspect that the overhead involved in collecting the "extra" fees would completely wipe out the extra revenue gained. For example, all those internet TV's, Wii's, PS3's (?) etc will need a new version of the iPlayer software that allows the input of the license code information somehow.
Actually I don't really have much of an issue in itself with collecting the license on non-license paying iPlayer users - however, the fact that it'll completely cream-cracker the excellent "get_iplayer" utility that I use every week to grab a load of radio programmes, that I couldn't access "live", is a major disappointment. I can't really see the Beeb allowing whatever system is used to enforce the license requirement being available to the developers of such tools - because, of course, we're not supposed to be using them anyway. :(
No-one\'s commented on an interesting point - the Beeb seems content not to apply the license fee to iPlayer users, and it\'s the government that seems to be forcing the issue. I wonder why...
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Hands up if the cynic in you has a strong feeling that said license law change will merely eliminate the \'TV tuner\' requirement, thus forcing all computer owners to pay for the licence regardless of if they own a TV.
*raises*
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Originally Posted by
aidanjt
Hands up if the cynic in you has a strong feeling that said license law change will merely eliminate the 'TV tuner' requirement, thus forcing all computer owners to pay for the licence regardless of if they own a TV.
*raises*
*raises*
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
Quote:
Originally Posted by
pauldarkside
@scaryjim The point I was getting at was that the Hexus article says "only a small percentage (0.2 percent) of its viewers use the iPlayer." That's completely different to what the Guardian are saying; "only 0.2% of households watch only catch-up television, with no live viewing, each week." Those two quotes don't mean the same thing.
Yeah, I got that - I was just pointing out that the 0.2% of households that *only* watch iPlayer is still actually quite a large number...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rob_B
I'd be happy with an ad supported iPlayer (doen't that happen overseas if you access BBC services?) - but that just won't happen.
I didn't think the BBC was allowed to run advertising except for its own products. If they're going to go for general advertising then they can ditch the license fee full stop and become a proper commercial station. A better plan would be to sell the rights to catch-up TV to sites like seesaw (I believe they already do this with some shows), who can then slap whatever advertising they want on it to recoup the cost of the licensing.
EDIT: it turns out that seesaw is no more. Anyone know what happened to them?
EDIT2: apparently, this happened to it.
Re: News - BBC licence fee may soon be mandatory for iPlayer users
I have a problem with this myself and my partner are not married, we only need one TV licence for the house, it is in her name, however the TV licensing people seem unable to grasp this fact, and I get threatening letters every now and them which I have given up even responding to, (every time you buy a TV/reciever the shop has to send in your name). If we have to have one for Iplayer, they will probably insist it is for the licence holder only, not member of the household.