Read more.EU Court of Justice advisory says such businesses should get safe harbour, like ISPs.
Read more.EU Court of Justice advisory says such businesses should get safe harbour, like ISPs.
How do you stop copyright infringements without any user monitoring?
Blacklist sites known to provide content that breaches copyright? Relatively easy even on most consumer routers...
I believe the issue is that you should make some attempt, not that you can guarantee total compliance.
That is a good idea from the point of view of a business owner who doesn't want a small group of users hogging all the bandwidth. However, it is ludicrous to expect companies that provide free WIFI to exercise complete control over their users' activity. Indeed, it was found that this requirement was onerous for ISPs, who have far more resources available to them than small business owners!
I'm thinking the same - as long as the "free Wifi provider" can demonstrate that they'd made a "reasonable" (by man-on-the-Clapham-omnibus standard) effort to stop IP infringement then I'd be more than happy to grant them a legal safe harbour. I'd be worried about unscrupulous providers from using the "it wasn't me mate" defence when they get caught downloading torrents to put on CD's to sell (under the counter of course) to customers. Of course if they had logs to prove it was a customer and not them....
In a sane world we'd be able to suggest that perhaps the copyright holders themselves provide a blacklist of known bad sites that they'd want blocked. After all, they seem to have the resources and inclination to chase down content theives, whereas "Peggy's Cafe" on the corner most certainly has neither.
Don't want to get all gushy, but I'm kind of glad when I see the high judiciary showing such common sense as this - well done EU court system!
I suspect that will be the cry from the entertainment industry - it risks giving business owners essentially carte blanche to using their open customer wifi to download/share copyrighted material, and of course once it's public knowledge it also means pirates can use open public wifi knowing that the provider isn't at risk of prosecution and they're unlikely to get caught.
"In a perfect world... spammers would get caught, go to jail, and share a cell with many men who have enlarged their penises, taken Viagra and are looking for a new relationship."
I install Sophos UTM Firewalls and they actually have a regularly updated category called "Illegal UK" which is a categorisation of all websites that are considered by UK legislation illegal and to be blocked. That should be enough to say you've "gone to reasonable grounds to protect" copyright interests without compromising public freedom with security systems.
scaryjim (18-03-2016)
This is excellent news. Hopefully it will mean more free wifi spots without having to sign up via web page or only getting 30 mins free.
Well, part of that is for marketing, and the charge may be to offset the cost of the connection, but for businesses like cafes and coffee bars, who offer it as part of their service (and the cost is absorbed as an overhead and incorporated into the product they are offering) it is good news.
(\__/)
(='.'=)
(")_(")
Been helped or just 'Like' a post? Use the Thanks button!
My broadband speed - 750 Meganibbles/minute
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)