Company car = German, pah
How about an Alfa Giulietta.
I presume the 235bhp variant would be out of your budget, but plenty of very nice toys lower down.
The carbon figures are pretty good across the range which is nice for tax, but don't believe the petrol mpg figures. For the petrol I hear people get mpg in the 30's. Probably because they switch the electronics to sport mode so they can get the biggest grin