Originally Posted by
krazy_olie
In case anyone does a search for this kind of thing adding the solution/result.
Turns out the dvi port on the monitor is screwed, as a result not sending the correct data to the computer/graphics card. So it work when connected with a vga cable. Interestingly older graphics cards would not boot up properly at all resulting in a black screen.
However it seems that new chipsets like the gtx 460 assume that there is some generic television or monitor at the end so output something that would usually be sensible. Had the monitor been a normal resolution and not 16:10 it would still work on DVI-D (digital). Personally I think it's quite impressive that you find out about features on new stuff you didn't even know existed.
VGA mode is a pain though, having to get the position pixel perfect and it's a bit blurry but it'll do until I get a new monitor.