i personally think top gear is a lot better.. its actually funny at times, with fun features, rather than just stuff about cars.. they find interesting ways to test cars, and i think thats good. the crash stuff on 5th gear is more interesting however..
the 200mph thing would have been good if they'd actually done it, but spreading a feature over 2 series is just crap. i like the way its an hour long now.. but the competition is ALWAYS bollox 'we're giving away our favourite aston, which happens to be 30 years old, rusty, and broken. but its still our favourite '. what a pile of bull
incidentally, i've been watching a load of top gear episodes from 89-90 of late, and they're ok, but dull, a bit like 5th gear imo.