I just flicked through an old 2001 issue of PC Format, where it has the 'top 20 games of 2002' (thats the first joke). Some of this top 20 include.....
Die Hard: Nakatomi Plaza
Unreal 2
Doom 3
Deus Ex 2
Colin McRae Rally 3.0
Sid Meier's Simgolf (eh?!)
Master of Orion 3
Republic: The Revolution
IGI 2
Thief III
C & C Renegade
Iron Storm
Uhhhh yea, all those games were great wern't they? If there's one moral from this mag, it's don't believe any hype