Firelord, totally agree with you about the charging. BUT, how can a hospital member of staff determin whether the individual is someone who's drunk and had an accident from his own stupidity, and someone who's had a nice drink but been mugged on the way home, for example?
As usual there's no easy answer to the problem and there's rarely a right or wrong answer. But people seem to be more and more opinionated these days that in someone's eyes you'll be right, in others you'll be speaking out of your a-hole.
Also, about your asthma and going to the pub comment, I think it's wrong to force smokers to stop smoking in he pub, but some pubs should take it upon themselves to ban smoking for those who want it, like yourself. I sympathise with your situation, but if I had bad enough asthma that smoking really agitated, I wouldn't go to a smokey pub.