Steve,
A few likkle questions.
Do we know what sort of price-range "cheapish" encompasses?
I ask because I suspect that progressive output and cheapish don't usually appear in the same sentence.
Preferences for analogue or Freeview?
My own preference would be to have both but if I could only have one - because of pricing or some other reason - then I'd choose Freeview.
But Freeview reception isn't as widespread as analogue so it would be wise to do a post-code check for Freeview reception for the place where the PVR is going to live. The checker is on
Freeview's home page.